The following 37 schools participate in the league:
- Aquinas
- Brighton
- Brockport
- Canandaigua
- Charlotte
- Churchville-Chili
- East
- Fairport
- Gananda
- Gates-Chili
- Geneva
- Greece Arcadia
- Greece Athena
- Greece Odyssey
- Greece Olympia
- Harley/Alendale Columbia
- Hilton
- Honeoye-Falls Lima
- Kendall
- Marshall
- McQuaid
- Mercy
- Monroe
- Newark
- NorthWest College Prep
- Penfield
- Pittsford Mendon
- Pittsford Sutherland
- School of the Arts
- Spencerport
- STEM
- Victor
- Wayne
- Webster Schroeder
- Webster Thomas
- West Irondequoit
- Wilson